JurgenV wrote: ↑Wed Mar 18, 2020 4:59 am
After my actually quite nice results with a steel string falcate braced 000 style guitar I thought I can easily adapt a classical guitar to falcate bracing. Little did I know

I should have believed John Parchem build description and stayed with the bracing height for steel strings. What I did was to reduce the brace height to get the flexural rigity to the values I found in the design book. Not the best idea. I closed the box yesterday and cleaned up everything and naturally I did the frequency analysis with VA.
T(1,1)1= 105Hz
T(1,1)2=183Hz
T(1,1)3= 249Hz
Means that would be a very low T(1,1)2 after the binding and gluing the bridge.
Looks like I have to take the top off again. Any suggestions on how to do that the best way without damaging the sides and/or the back?
Never did that before
And I have to find a new top ...
Hi Jurgen, wie gehts??
I am building my first falcate classical and have got to the point where I was planning to use the Flexural rigidity guidelines in the book (section 4.4.5) to determine the height of the primary and secondary braces. If I understand the "books" correctly the size of the brace needs to be determined so that the soundboard and braces have an EI of around 15 to 20 Nm2 50mm in front of the bridge. I had imagined that this needed to be done for each guitar, taking into account the different pieces of wood used.
From your first post in this thread, it sounds like that's what you were doing. My first attempt at the spreadsheet is giving me very high EI for 10mm high braces (5mm thick) which would indicate the braces need to be much smaller. Is that what your calculations showed? Would you mind sharing what brace height you calculated for your first top?
This is the opposite of John Parchems experience above (he calculated higher braces) so I'm more than a little puzzled. Tonight's job is to recheck the spreadsheet.
How did you determine brace height on the second top?
I note that more experienced builders than I simply leave the braces at 10mm plus or minus a bit.
Vielen danke
RIchard